Paul Rudd

Paul

Steve Coogan

Erasmus

Jack Gore

Bill

Alison Pill

Melissa

Jake McDorman

Beau

Jesse Luken

Director

Lora Martinez-Cunningham

Ms. Garcia

Sarah Minnich

Crack Head Lady

Stafford Douglas

Caterer

Jacob Browne

Judge Pierce

Frances Lee McCain

Doris

Josey Smith

Whitney

Kate Walsh

Kate

Jenny Gabrielle

Betty

Monique Candelaria

Officer Guttierez

Alexandra Guarnaschelli

Alex Guarnaschelli

Courtney Cunningham

Paramedic

Drew Droege

Drew

Marie Wagenman

Little Girl

Cassandra Rochelle Fetters

Party Goer

Evan Bittencourt

Tino

Rodrigo Tactaquin

Biker

Mark Rowe

Suburban Dad

Eric Womack

Officer Forrest

Richard Beal

Church Member

Jordyn Aurora Aquino

Leticia

Clint Obenchain

Waiter

J. Nathan Simmons

Wise Man #1

Alexander Daniel Pimentel

Suburban Dad's Friend

Kristin K. Berg

Taco Bell Manager

Emma Armstrong

Checkout Girl

Stephen Conn

Christmas Reveler / Church decorator / Lighting tech

Michael E. Stogner

Drunk Santa (uncredited)

Amanda Quintana-Bowles

Christmas Reveler

Alison Grainger

Taco Bell Patron

Rick Tadra

Maddy

Patrick V. Murphy

Party goer

Ian Morris

Bill's Friend

Ronnie Gomez

Wise Man #3

Jeremiah Fresquez

Student #1

Viola Valdez

Parishioner

Justin Lotz

Wise Man #2

Mason Howell

Bills Friend

Sheila Eden

Tango Wife (uncredited)

Sylvie Grontis Hagan

Teacher (uncredited)

Amy Emily Stack

Inmate Visitor (uncredited)