Eva Victor

Agnes Ward

Naomi Ackie

Lydie

Lucas Hedges

Gavin

Louis Cancelmi

Preston Decker

Kelly McCormack

Natasha

John Carroll Lynch

Pete

Hettienne Park

Eleanor Winston

E.R. Fightmaster

Fran

Cody Reiss

Devin

Jordan Mendoza

Logan

Anabel Graetz

Professor Wilkinson

Jonathan Myles

The Man She Thought Was Decker

Danny Diaz

Young Guy

Marc Carver

Doctor

Liz Bishop

Elizabeth

Natalie Rotter-Laitman

Claire

Francesca D'Uva

Grocery Store Gianna

Alison Wachtler

Clerk

David J. Curtis

Judge

Priscilla Manning

Andrea Fuller

Kate Fitzgerald

Tracey Dover

Jesse Gabbard

Hector Woguard

Lucien Spelman

Kevin Faber

Tom Ford

Walter

Celeste Oliva

Sophie

Chhoyang Cheshatsang

Thomas

Conor Sweeney

Jeremy

Lensley Miles Adam

Baby Jane

Langston Shelby Moore

Baby Jane Double

Noochie the Cat

Olga the Cat

Eric Josif

Additional Voicework

Tierre Diaz

Juror (uncredited)

Casey McNeal

Juror (uncredited)

Jim Powers

Shopper (uncredited)

Debora Strout

Court Reporter (uncredited)